Proof of Lancaster Menu (Update 2025)

Welcome to Proof of Lancaster, a gem nestled in the heart of Lancaster, PA. This upscale cocktail bar features a menu that celebrates culinary creativity with a focus on small plates, perfect for sharing. With dishes like the spectacular short rib bao buns and a picturesque charcuterie board, guests are treated to an exquisite dining experience that combines elegance with bold flavors.

Each dish reflects a meticulous attention to detail, showcasing the chef's skill in balancing fresh ingredients. Reviewers rave about the delicious creativity—from delectable creative seafood options to the unforgettable butternut squash cheesecake. The atmosphere is equally inviting; its refined, speak-easy design and excellent service provide a relaxing backdrop ideal for date nights or a special occasion.

Whether you're savoring expertly crafted cocktails or indulging in delightful small plates, Proof of Lancaster promises an unforgettable culinary journey. Prepare to be impressed!

Whites

Langlois Cremant

Vivant Pet Nat

Olianas Vermentino

Chateau Jaron Rose

Frenzy Sauvignon Blanc

Kir Yianni Assyrtiko

Alexander Valley Chardonnay

Decibel Rose

Proof Old-Fashioned

Field Notes

The Tipping Point

The Cure

Daytrader

Bygone

Cocktails

Confections

Meyer's Lemon Cake

US$14.00

Chocolate Lava Cake

US$14.00

Colossal Cheesecake

US$12.00

Key Lime Tart

Housemade Vanilla Bean Ice Cream

Seasonal Housemade Ice Cream Flavor

Torta Al Limone Gelato

Blood Orange Sorbet

Frozen Indulgences

Cinco De Mayo Specials

Classic Margarita

US$14.00

Mezcalita

US$14.00

Oysters On The Half Shell

US$2.00

Rotating Handheld Special

Sustenance

Aperitivi

Montenegro Highball

US$12.00

Spring Fling

US$14.00

Negroni Sbagliato

US$12.00

Two For The Show

US$13.00

Orange Italian Mule

US$14.00

Americano

US$4.00

Latte

US$5.00

Loose Leaf Tea

US$3.00

Coffee & Tea

Kentucky Derby Specials

Mint Julep

US$14.00

Kentucky Buck

US$15.00

Kale & Romaine

Oysters On The Half Shell

Local Beet Salad

Burrata

Steak Tartare

Seared Sea Scallops

Pink Oyster Mushroom Toast

Wild Sockeye Carpaccio

Elysian Fields Lamb

Chilled Shrimp & Lobster

Crab Cake

Small Plates

Charcuterie

Mortadella

Finocchiona

Speck

Bresaola

Comtesse Marion Pinot Noir

J.h. Meyer Pinot Noir

Vini Di Maremma

Gilgal Cabernet-Merlot

Copertino Riserva

Naturschonheit

Bodega Muriel Crianza

Chateau Croix Des Gentis

I'm Not Salty Espresso Martini

US$16.00

Black Forest Espresso Martini

US$14.00

Cafe Negroni

US$14.00

Panzanella Salad

US$16.00

Spicy Crab & Tuna Rolls

US$18.00

Bruschetta

US$18.00

Seafood Risotto

US$28.00

Schnitzel Iberico

US$26.00

Steak Tartare

US$24.00

Seared Day Boat Scallops

US$30.00

Five Onion Soup

US$18.00

French Dip

US$22.00

New England Lobster Roll

US$24.00

Others